I have many thoughts, but it took me a couple of days to write this, and then I didn't want to bury it under the Golden Globes liveblog, so:
The first two weeks of 2012 have been kind of nutty in the book world. It seems like a ton of writers, mostly in the YA genre (and a couple of their agents) decided to denounce, harass and/or retaliate against book bloggers who gave them negative reviews. Twitter, GoodReads, blogs, leaked email, ~drama~. Jane at Dear Author has a really interesting discussion of the divide between reader and author paradigms, which I think explains a lot about what has happened, and she describes and links to a number of incidents. And that post doesn't even cover all of them; new writer-reader spats are still cropping up. And because a lot of this is happening on GoodReads, this isn't even like the classic literary lion/professional critic feuds of old. These are writers attacking readers who have a lot less power; I'm pretty sure most of them are amateur reviewers who just do it for love of books. For a general taste, see "Diary of an Author" from Meljean Brooks, which starts here, but the fourth entry is where it turns into a Greatest Hits reenactment of the last two weeks. "LORD COCKMONSTER IS NOT AN ASSHOLE AND IT SAYS SO RIGHT ON PAGE 374!!!!!" People, much of that is paraphrased from things that actually happened. It is that bad.
( The lessons of Clawy McWolfenstein )

The first two weeks of 2012 have been kind of nutty in the book world. It seems like a ton of writers, mostly in the YA genre (and a couple of their agents) decided to denounce, harass and/or retaliate against book bloggers who gave them negative reviews. Twitter, GoodReads, blogs, leaked email, ~drama~. Jane at Dear Author has a really interesting discussion of the divide between reader and author paradigms, which I think explains a lot about what has happened, and she describes and links to a number of incidents. And that post doesn't even cover all of them; new writer-reader spats are still cropping up. And because a lot of this is happening on GoodReads, this isn't even like the classic literary lion/professional critic feuds of old. These are writers attacking readers who have a lot less power; I'm pretty sure most of them are amateur reviewers who just do it for love of books. For a general taste, see "Diary of an Author" from Meljean Brooks, which starts here, but the fourth entry is where it turns into a Greatest Hits reenactment of the last two weeks. "LORD COCKMONSTER IS NOT AN ASSHOLE AND IT SAYS SO RIGHT ON PAGE 374!!!!!" People, much of that is paraphrased from things that actually happened. It is that bad.
( The lessons of Clawy McWolfenstein )