So far, most people dislike the movie, whether they were book fans or not, so it's probably a badly done movie either way... I guess my argument is that even if the adaptation is really loose, the movie can be good in its own right. Which does not seem to be true in this case, but I can't say from official experience, having not read the books or seen the movie yet.
no subject
Date: 2007-10-09 05:48 am (UTC)Thanks for the reply!