Yes, Shawn! :D It's from "Scary Sherry: Bianca's Toast," when they're about to go rescue Jules, and Gus stops Shawn to rattle off a list of rules about the 'haunted' building. That's Shawn's "OMG OK" face.

...I watch Psych too much.

I agree, I think Dulé would be much prettier. Roday's nose is too big. I mean, I love his nose, but it is a masculine nose. Not so effective for dragging it up. Plus he's always all stubbly.