Ughh... I'm still not sure about Sherlock Holmes, yet. Still not sure.

Although, everything RDJr touches lately turns to gold. Also, he is pretty.

Someone in the last link you gave commented that they were rooting for a Hugh Laurie/Stephen Fry combo for Holmes and Watson, and I hadn't even CONSIDERED the awesome possibilities of that. Hugh really would've nailed it.

Ah well. Until it hits the big screen, I await in timid anticipation.